Andrew proposed to Nicole on January 19, 2014. That evening Andrew took Nicole to a Broadway Play and out to eat at S'Mac, a restaurant with about 30 different Mac N Cheeses. Andrew clearly knows his women's favorite food. He also knows Nicole can never make up her mind. So, as you can imagine, they were there for quite some time. After dinner, Andrew took Nicole to Central Park in Uptown Manhattan. As the two were walking through the park, and Nicole was wondering why they were walking in a park when it was 10 degrees out, Andrew walked Nicole to a swing set. As he was pushing her on the swing, he suddenly stopped, got on one knee and asked her to marry him. Of course Nicole said yes!